Today is setup, not the full Key Assignment. Next lesson you turn this brief into a short written comparison of your three pieces on one theme, and that comparison banks M4 KA1.
You leave today with one piece only: a KA1 Comparison Brief in your Communication Portfolio. It names your theme, your three pieces, and the analysis job you will take. That brief is a real written plan, and it is the only Portfolio entry from this lesson.
In order you will pick a shared theme, shortlist three pieces (mixed song, rap and poem preferred), check they contrast, then write the brief. If your period is shorter than 60 minutes, the brief still gets protected writing time at the end.
Before you write the brief, lock three things: a shared theme, three pieces that actually contrast, and what you will analyse.
| Term | What it means for you | Real example |
|---|---|---|
| Shared theme (one idea all three pieces carry) | Pick something specific enough to compare, not a vague word like "life" | Belonging, rather than "feelings" |
| Comparable (same theme, different enough treatment) | Mixed forms are preferred. Three quiet ballads on the same topic leave you with little to say. Same-form sets only work if the treatments clearly differ, and your brief must say how. | A soft poem, a driving rap, and a mid-tempo song on leaving home |
| Contribution plan (what you will analyse) | Name your part in writing so your individual work is clear in the Portfolio | "I will handle imagery and what the poem does to the reader" |
Worked model brief (teaching example; all three pieces invented):
Theme: leaving home. Pieces: Leaving at Dawn (song); Our Road (rap, about the street you grew up on); The Light Left On (poem, about the kitchen light left on). My contribution: I will analyse imagery and emotional effect in the poem, and how the silence on the page does different work from the beat in the rap.
That is the shape of the brief you will write today. Next lesson turns it into the full comparison.
Build your shortlist. In a group, go round once so everyone adds a theme idea before anyone argues for one. Capture theme ideas and candidate pieces with title and form. You need three pieces that can sit on the same page without saying the same thing twice. Mixed song, rap and poem is preferred; any mix is fine if the treatments contrast.
Name your three strongest candidates and check them against the criteria. If two pieces say almost the same thing, swap the weaker one for a piece with real contrast so you still have something to analyse. Decide which three you will take forward and be ready to say why.
Write your KA1 Comparison Brief. This is today's real communication output: a short written plan naming theme, three pieces, group or solo, and your individual analytical job. Use the page as your working draft.
Completeness is the bar. Every brief needs four named parts: shared theme; three pieces with forms; group or solo; your contribution plan. Aim for about 80 to 200 words when you have time; a complete four-part brief can be shorter and still counts.
When you are happy with it, copy this exact brief into your Communication Portfolio as m4_l97_ka1_brief_JM.txt (replace JM with your own initials, or use your usual document format). That file is today's Portfolio entry.
You're previewing this lesson. Get full access to this lesson and hundreds more — each one ready to teach, with interactive activities, printable resources and pupil progress tracking built in.