Intermediate
60 mins
Teacher/Student led
+75 XP
Pupils work on their own device

Film and Text Comparison Workshop, Part 1 (KA4 prep)

Settle your film and related text pair for a future comparison task. Choose four or five focal points that highlight differences between the versions, decide how you will present your findings, and write the KA4 Comparison Brief. Written for a 60-minute slot; a trim path for shorter periods is in the teacher notes.

Teacher Class Feed

Load previous activity

    1 - Getting Started ~5 mins

    Today you choose the pair you will use for M3 KA4: one film, one related text, four or five focal points, and the medium you will present in. By the end you will have a short brief filed in your Communication Portfolio that you (and your teacher) can build from later.

    Tip

    If you already picked a film-and-text pair in an earlier lesson, use that. If not, start from a film and a related text you have actually finished, so you can point at real moments in both without guessing.

    Key point

    Narrow is the point. Four solid angles beat a full plot retell, and a clear brief means a later make session does not stall on choosing.

    2 - What a Strong Brief Looks Like ~8 mins

    You will build your own shortlist next. This is the shape only.

    TermWhat it meansExample shape
    Focal pointOne angle you will actually compare (four or five, not the whole plot)How silence works in a tense scene
    Related textThe written piece beside the film, sharing enough ground to compareA short story beside a short-film adaptation of the same story
    Presentation mediumThe form of your KA4 piece, chosen now so a later session is making, not decidingSide-by-side page, slides, or poster
    Worked example

    Compact worked brief (invented pair for structure only): Film: a 12-minute short about a late bus home. Related text: a two-page short story on the same journey. Focal points: (1) opening mood, (2) what the main character never says, (3) how the ending is framed, (4) what the audience is made to feel. Medium: one-page side-by-side document. Grounds sentence: both follow the same late journey home, so each focal point can be checked on the page and on screen.

    Key point

    A common classroom pattern is a stage drama students already know beside its film version, or a short story beside a short-film adaptation they have actually seen. No full plot retell. Four angles only.

    3 - Build Your Shortlist ~10 mins

    List candidate pairs and the focal points each pair could support. Aim for more than you will keep. Next you will cut down to four or five.

    Pairs and possible focal points

    4 - Weigh the Focal Points ~15 mins

    Key point

    Score each focal point for your pair. Put more weight on the criteria that matter most (especially evidence in both versions, and real difference). Keep the four or five that rise to the top. Then fill in the decision sheet below: your pair, the ones you keep, one you cut and why, and your medium.

    Tip

    Start from the focal points you just listed on your shortlist. Add those first. Use the two starter rows only if you need extras.

    Which focal points earn a place?

    5 - Write Your KA4 Comparison Brief ~17 mins

    Key point

    This is the page a later make session will build from. Write the film, related text, four or five focal points, your medium, and one grounds sentence, then save it to your Communication Portfolio. The shortlist and weighting were warm-up; only this brief gets filed today.

    Tip

    Leave about 15 minutes for this step: it is the only Portfolio piece today. Write the brief, tighten anything thin, then paste the finished brief into your Communication Portfolio folder the same way you have banked earlier Module 3 entries. Save it as a plain text file named like m3_l88_ka4_brief_JM.txt (use your own initials instead of JM).

    Your KA4 Comparison Brief

    123learn · Online learning platform

    Unlock the full learning experience

    You're previewing this lesson. Get full access to this lesson and hundreds more — each one ready to teach, with interactive activities, printable resources and pupil progress tracking built in.

    Hundreds of curriculum-aligned lessons
    Interactive activities in every lesson
    Printable resources & progress tracking
    Copyright Notice
    This lesson is copyright of Coding Ireland 2017 - 2025. Unauthorised use, copying or distribution is not allowed.
    🍪 Our website uses cookies to make your browsing experience better. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more