You already know how to say a song slaps. That is a fan post. Today you write a critique: a short piece that names what the song does, who it is for, and what it does to you, with evidence from the words.
By the end you will have a 100–150 word Song Critique Draft for your Communication Portfolio, built on five parts: technique, theme, emotion, audience, and personal response.
Pick any song you know well and can quote one line from. If your class has the anchor song from Lesson 91, you can use that; if not, name another track and work from specific lines you remember.
A critique is not a score out of ten. It is a reasoned position with evidence. Use these three terms as you read and write today.
| Term | What it means for you | Real example |
|---|---|---|
| Critique: a reasoned judgement of what works, for whom, and why | Your draft must take a position and back it with lines from the song | Saying a slow first verse makes the loud chorus feel earned, rather than only calling it catchy |
| Audience: who the piece is speaking to | Name who would feel spoken to, and why the tone fits them | A quiet late-night song for people who have left home, not a festival crowd |
| Personal response: what the piece does to you | Root your reaction in a specific line, not a vague mood | One line about an empty seat on the school bus that made you stop the track |
Five-part shape for every critique: technique → theme → emotion → audience → personal response.
One worked sentence on a different song: "The alliteration in 'bright, broke and brave' makes the chorus bounce, so the theme of being young with no money sounds like freedom, not worry." That sentence already does technique and theme with evidence. You have heard the same move on tracks you already stream: a sound choice that carries the feeling before the line spells it out.
You are studying how a real critique is built so you can write yours next. Read the eight lines of Kitchen Light (an original worked example written for this lesson) once with the class, then read the model critique beside them. Spot how each of the five parts does its job and answer the two check questions. Your real listen-and-critique comes next on a song you choose.
Pick a song you know cold. Write your Song Critique Draft (100–150 words).
Use all five parts (technique, theme, emotion, audience, personal response) and quote at least one line. One strong draft is the Portfolio piece; use the tags as a quick self-check before you save. Copy the finished draft into your Communication Portfolio as m4_l95_song_critique_<your-initials>.docx.
Talk this through with the person beside you, or sit with it on your own:
The longer thinking belongs in your Reflective Journal when you next open it, not on this screen.
You're previewing this lesson. Get full access to this lesson and hundreds more — each one ready to teach, with interactive activities, printable resources and pupil progress tracking built in.