1 - Getting Started ~5 mins
Think of one technology you used today before school. A phone alarm? A bus or traffic app? A kettle that clicks off? What job did it do for you?
Today we will weigh real Irish technologies: not only what they can do, but when they help and when they get in the way.
Keep this light. Hands up for two or three everyday examples only. Do not hand out research cards or name the full judging list yet.
Hook question: Is the newest tool always the best tool for the job? Take one or two quick answers and leave the debate open.
Before the lesson: print one set of research cards per group (Card sets A, B and C below are authored in full in step 3). Push desks into groups of three or four. Have scrap paper and pencils ready for rough notes.
2 - Weighing a Technology ~6 mins
Three short words for today.
Advantage: a real help the tool gives you. Example: a bus tracker shows the next bus is five minutes away, so you are not guessing in the rain at a city stop.
Drawback: a real problem with that tool. Example: if the phone battery is dead, the tracker cannot help at all.
Setting: the place where the job happens. A busy city bus stop is one setting. A quiet rural stop with weak signal is another. The same tool can win in one place and lose in the other.
Our job is to compare two ways of doing the same job and say which suits which place.
Project only the short board text. Keep this to about six minutes so groups meet the cards soon. Use the table below as your own reference while you model one worked comparison aloud.
| Concept | Why it matters | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Advantage — a real benefit of using a technology for a job | It stops us praising a gadget just because it is new; we name what it actually improves | A bus tracker can show the next bus is five minutes away so you do not wait in the rain guessing |
| Drawback — a real cost or problem of using that technology | Every tool has a price: battery, signal, cost, skill or who is left out. Naming drawbacks keeps the comparison honest | If your phone battery is dead, the bus tracker cannot help you at all |
| Setting — the place where the job is done | A tool that suits one Irish place can fail in another, so our answer is never just "always use the app" | A weather app suits a kitchen planning a beach day; a printed notice may suit a farmyard with weak signal |
| Technology choice — picking the option that best matches the job and the place | Engineers and citizens both choose tools by purpose, not by fashion | For a short local walk you might check the sky; for a long car journey you might check a weather app first |
Worked comparison (model aloud before groups start)
I wonder: is a live bus tracker always better than a paper timetable at the stop?
I compare (using evidence from the cards): Tracker helps: live arrival time, fewer wasted waits. Tracker problems: needs phone, battery and signal; can fail if the feed is wrong. Paper timetable helps: always readable, no battery. Paper timetable problems: buses run late and the paper cannot tell you that.
I conclude: the tracker suits a busy city stop with good signal; the paper timetable still suits a quiet rural stop when your phone is dead. The setting decides.
Misconception to head off: children may treat "advantage" as "I like it" and "drawback" as "I don't". Push them toward job-linked reasons: speed, how sure you can be, cost, who can use it, what happens when it fails.
Nature of STEM thread: Irish daily life now runs on tools that did not exist a generation ago (real-time passenger apps, farm sensors, phone weather). Those tools changed routines, but they also created new problems such as screen time and dependence on signal. Scientists and engineers keep redesigning them as needs change.
3 - Research One Irish Technology ~22 mins
Irish life runs on tools your grandparents never had, and on older ways that still work. Your group becomes the experts on one of them.
You get one Irish everyday technology. Read your research cards. Compare two ways of doing the same job: with the technology and without it (the older or simpler way).
Work in this order together:
- Read all five cards in your set (take turns).
- Say the job in one short sentence.
- Name the two ways: with the technology and without it.
- Pick at least three things you will judge by (use the board list or swap one).
- For each judge-by, note a help and a problem for each way (short phrases are fine).
- Agree one place where the technology suits best and one place where the simpler way suits better.
Things we will judge by (tick three, or swap one): speed · how sure you can be · cost · who can use it · what happens when it fails · who is left out.
Before the lesson
Print one full card set per group (A, B or C). Three or four groups can share the same set if the class is large; aim for all three technologies in use across the room so the later presentations have variety.
How to run it
Give each group about 22 minutes. Project the pupil checklist so every group follows the same order. Circulate and press for judge-bys linked to the job, not vague likes. Prompt: Who is this for? What breaks first? Who is left out?
Groups jot rough notes on scrap paper; the neat comparison goes on the Investigation Journal page in the next step.
Full research card texts (print exactly)
Card set A — Bus tracker
Card A1 — Job:
- Catch a bus to town.
- Know when the next bus comes so you do not wait too long in the rain.
Card A2 — With it (live bus tracker):
- Phone app or stop screen shows live arrival times.
- Uses the bus's location to estimate when it will arrive.
- You can see if the bus is about three minutes or fifteen minutes away.
- Needs a charged phone or a working stop screen, plus a signal.
Card A3 — Without it (paper timetable):
- Printed times fixed to the stop or kept in a leaflet.
- Lists planned times only.
- Needs no battery; works in any light you can read by.
- Cannot tell you the bus is stuck in traffic or cancelled.
- In rural areas the gap between buses can be long, so a late bus matters a lot.
Card A4 — Watch-outs in Irish life:
- Live bus info grew as phones and mobile data became common.
- Helps workers, secondary pupils and visitors plan journeys.
- New habits: people stare at phones at the stop.
- People may feel stuck if the battery dies or the feed freezes.
Card A5 — Places to try:
- Busy city stop with good signal.
- Quiet rural stop with weak signal.
- Younger child with no phone.
- Tourist who does not know the route.
- Dark winter evening in heavy rain.
Card set B — Weather app
Card B1 — Job:
- Know if tomorrow suits a match, a farm job, or a trip to the coast.
- Get a useful weather picture in time to plan.
Card B2 — With it (weather app):
- Phone app can show hourly rain chance, wind, temperature and warnings for your area.
- Many Irish families check Met Éireann information through an app or website.
- Updates can arrive quickly when a storm track changes.
- Needs a device, battery, data or Wi-Fi, and skill to read the symbols.
- Some apps ask for location so the forecast matches where you are.
Card B3 — Without it (sky, local knowledge, radio or TV):
- People still read the sky, feel the wind, and listen to a set-time forecast.
- Farmers and sailors often combine local knowledge with official forecasts.
- Needs no personal data; works if the phone is dead.
- Update may be less frequent and less local than a live app map.
Card B4 — Watch-outs in Irish life:
- Atlantic weather can change fast.
- Better forecasts help fishing, farming, school sports and road safety.
- Apps can pull people back to screens many times a day.
- Some families set rules about how often children may check phones.
Card B5 — Places to try:
- Planning a beach day two days ahead (kitchen table).
- Deciding whether to cut silage this morning (farmyard).
- A classroom with no pupil phones.
- A hill walk where signal drops.
- A storm warning night when power might fail.
Card set C — Smart farming tools
Card C1 — Job:
- Know how animals or crops are doing.
- Spot problems early so feed, water or fertiliser are not wasted.
Card C2 — With it (sensors, tags or farm apps):
- Some Irish farms use sensors on gates, tanks or animals.
- Apps can show alerts on a phone.
- A tank sensor can warn that water is low.
- A tag can hint that an animal is less active than usual.
- Data can be checked from the yard or the kitchen.
- Tools cost money; they need power, signal and training.
Card C3 — Without it (walk the land and look):
- Farmers walk fields, check troughs, watch animal behaviour and keep simple notebooks.
- Needs no subscription; builds deep local knowledge.
- Takes time; a problem in a far field may be noticed later.
- Harder on a large farm or in bad weather.
Card C4 — Watch-outs in Irish life:
- Irish farming is a big part of rural life and food supply.
- Digital tools can cut waste and support animal welfare.
- Not every farm has strong broadband.
- Some families worry more screens mean less time noticing the land with their own eyes.
Card C5 — Places to try:
- Large farm with fields far from the yard.
- Small holding next to the house.
- Young farmer who likes apps.
- Older relative who prefers walking the stock.
- Storm night when you cannot safely cross fields in the dark.
Differentiation
Support: give the group two ready judge-by slips (speed; what happens when it fails) and ask them to add one more of their own. Stretch: insist on one advantage and one drawback for each way of doing the job, plus two different places with opposite recommendations.
Safety: none beyond ordinary classroom movement. If any group uses a class tablet to glance at a real app as an extra, keep it teacher-supervised and brief; the cards alone are enough.
4 - Record the Comparison ~10 mins
On your Investigation Journal page, capture your group's comparison. Short phrases are fine; you do not need full sentences.
Use this checklist as you write:
- Name the job and the technology.
- Way with it / way without it.
- Three things you judged by.
- Helps and problems linked to those judge-bys.
- Who wins where: one place for the technology, one place for the simpler way, and why.
This is the paper recording beat. Each pupil uses the platform-provided ComparisonTable Investigation Journal page (listed under recording_sheets). Print those provided pages before the lesson. Tell pupils what to record; do not describe where boxes sit on the page.
Must-record content (matches the pupil checklist):
- Name of the technology and the job it does
- Way 1 (with the technology) and Way 2 (without it)
- At least three judge-bys used
- Advantage and drawback notes linked to those judge-bys (phrases allowed)
- Two places with a recommended option for each, plus a short why
Keep card facts separate from opinion: first what the cards say the tool does, then what the group concludes.
If a group is stuck, send them back to Card 4 and Card 5 of their set. Model one spoken line if needed: Job: catch the bus. With: live tracker. Without: paper timetable. Judge by: speed, signal, battery. City stop: tracker. Rural stop, dead phone: paper.
5 - Present Which Suits Which Setting ~10 mins
Teach the class something they could actually use at a real bus stop, farm or kitchen table.
Each presenting group has about one minute. Tell us: the job, the two options, one strong advantage, one strong drawback, and which option suits which place.
Listeners: be ready to ask one respectful question about a place the group did not mention.
How to run the presentations (10 minutes total)
You will not hear every group live in ten minutes. Plan for three live groups (about one minute speaking plus one short listener question each). For the other groups, run a quick journal-page gallery: neighbouring groups swap Investigation Journal pages for one minute and read the two place recommendations.
If time is very tight, hear two live groups and spend the rest on the gallery; revoice one strong contrast yourself so every technology still gets a class mention.
Listen for: job-linked advantages and drawbacks; a genuine place contrast; no claim that the app is always best.
Revoice examples: So your group is saying the tracker wins when signal is strong, but the paper timetable still matters when the battery is dead.
Protect step 6: if this step starts to overrun, stop after three live slots (or move earlier to the gallery). Do not steal the big-questions talk; that synthesis is part of the learning, not an optional extra.
No posters: the journal page is the record and the gallery artefact.
Unlock the full learning experience
You're previewing this lesson. Get full access to this lesson and hundreds more — each one ready to teach, with interactive activities, printable resources and pupil progress tracking built in.
This lesson is copyright of Coding Ireland 2017 - 2025. Unauthorised use, copying or distribution is not allowed.